Did Karbala take place?

What an excellent question for the rijalists....i await some hopefully interesting replies!

Ilme rijal is introduced by the ahle sunat scholors which later adopted by the shia scholors all these facts r illustrated in a book named{روضات الجنات فں
{ROZATUL JANAAT FI AHWAL O ULLEMA WA SADAT}wiich is written by the great mujahid syed mohammad baqir kho ansari in this book he acceped that the ahle sunat imam shafi is the founder of ilm e rija
to my research it is totally opposite to the to teachings of quran and masomeens a.s bec -ause quran says u should confirm the words not the person who talking may allah put down his curse at such mujtahideen who walk against the ahdees of our masomeen a.s i invite all of u 2 study the 18# sermon of Hazrat Ali a.s in Nehjul Balagha in which my Imam has open the veil which such cursed mujatadeen wear.Lanat at muqasireen beshumar

I would also like to add that after seeing the current trend from the 'rijalists' in regards to the events and personalities (a.s) of Kerbala, it seems as if questions like the above would play right into their hands.

This would certainly be a good question for them but only to strengthen their plight to dismiss the importance of Kerbala and Azadari

scientists question by saying, does god exist? the muslims rephrase it by asking, does god NOT exist? so prove if god doesnt exist first which opens up a wider debate...


it would be interesting to see if there is any kind of proof out there that supports the event of karbala not occuring?

silat, thats true, everythings been mixed soo wel in peoples hearts, its hard to distinguish between what is from the enemies and what isn't, it would be a good thing if one could place enemy hadiths about karbala on one side and aima (saw), sahabis (as) hadiths on the other on a site?

this is such a big thing, the entire shia world runs on these hadiths, the enemies will be the exaggerators and the ones that lower maulas (saw) status, surely the enemies would do this in karbala, they would do anything to lower maulas (saw) status.

like you said silat warrior, hadiths that give a hint of the status of maula (Saw) are ignored and rejected and hadiths by the enemies are accepted, possibly lowering the status of maula (saw). Does that not make one worse then the enemy?